Yellow Letters vs Postcards: Cost and When Each Wins (2026)
By Moe Ameen, founder of BILT · Published · Updated
Postcards cost less per piece and get read without opening; yellow letters cost more but look personal and hold a longer message. At USPS prices effective October 4, 2026, a stamped postcard is $0.65 and a stamped letter $0.82. Retail postcards must be 3.5 by 5 inches to 4.25 by 6 inches. Test both formats on halves of the same list before committing.
Key takeaways
- A stamped postcard costs $0.65 and a stamped letter $0.82 (USPS, Oct 4, 2026).
- Retail postcard prices only apply from 3.5 x 5 in. up to 4.25 x 6 in.
- Postcards are read on sight; letters have to get opened first.
- Yellow letters look personal, which suits inherited and distressed owners.
- Split-test both formats on the same list with separate phone numbers.
A yellow letter is a short, handwritten-style note on yellow lined paper, usually in a hand-addressed envelope. A postcard is a printed card read the moment it comes out of the mailbox.
They do different jobs. Here is what each costs today and how to pick one for a given list.
How much do yellow letters and postcards cost?
On postage alone, a stamped postcard costs $0.65 and a stamped First-Class letter $0.82 at USPS prices effective October 4, 2026.
Vendors that print and mail for you bundle postage in. On thanks.io's page, a 4x6 postcard was $1.18 pay-as-you-go, $0.77 on its $49-a-month Business plan and $0.64 on the $199-a-month Professional plan. Its windowed letter was $1.24, $0.83 and $0.79 on the same tiers, and thanks.io says Business and Professional rates go as Standard (Marketing) Mail.
| Postcard | Letter | |
|---|---|---|
| USPS stamped, First-Class | $0.65 | $0.82 (1 oz) |
| USPS presorted First-Class, 5-Digit | $0.453 | $0.621 (automation) |
| thanks.io pay-as-you-go, postage included | $1.18 (4x6) | $1.24 (windowed) |
| thanks.io Professional ($199/mo), postage included | $0.64 (4x6) | $0.79 (windowed) |
USPS Notice 123 (effective Oct 4, 2026) and thanks.io pricing, read November 4, 2026.
What size can a postcard be?
To get First-Class postcard prices at retail, a card must be rectangular, between 3.5 by 5 inches and 4.25 by 6 inches, and 0.007 to 0.016 inches thick.
Those limits are on USPS's Postal Explorer. A larger card, such as a 6x9, falls outside those retail card limits, so it won't get the $0.65 stamped postcard price. Check the real price with USPS or your vendor before you design.
When does a yellow letter work better than a postcard?
Yellow letters suit owners going through something personal, such as an inheritance, a divorce or a house they can't keep up, because they read like a note from a person.
The handwritten look and plain wording make the letter feel less like an ad, and the envelope keeps the message private from whoever else picks up the mail. The trade-off is that it has to be opened. An owner who tosses unopened mail never sees it.
When does a postcard work better than a letter?
Postcards suit large lists, repeat touches and simple offers, because the message is read without opening anything.
A postcard works well as the second or third touch after a letter, or when you mail a big list and need the lowest price per piece. It is also easier to keep recognizable from mailing to mailing. Avoid putting anything on a postcard the owner would not want a mail carrier or neighbor to read, such as a reference to a foreclosure filing.
How do you test letters against postcards?
Split one list in half at random, mail each half a different format in the same week, and give each format its own phone number.
Count calls and texts per number, then appointments and contracts per format, not only responses. A format that draws more "take me off your list" calls is not winning. BILT CRM sells extra phone numbers at $4 a month on Starter, which makes one number per format cheap, and logs the texts and calls on each.
Who is this for, and who should skip it?
Choose yellow letters if…
- The list is small and personal
- The situation is sensitive
- You can afford more per piece
Choose postcards if…
- The list is large
- This is a repeat touch
- Cost per piece decides the budget
Best for
- Yellow letters: inherited, probate, divorce and distressed-owner lists
- Postcards: large lists, repeat touches, simple offers
- Both: investors willing to split-test with separate phone numbers
Not ideal for
- Yellow letters at very high volume when the budget is tight
- Postcards that mention sensitive situations in plain view
- Choosing a format from someone else's results instead of testing your own
What else do people ask?
Do yellow letters have to be handwritten?
No. Most are printed in a handwriting-style font. thanks.io, for example, describes its handwriting as digitally rendered.
Should the envelope be hand-addressed?
A handwritten-style address and a real stamp make a letter look personal, which helps it get opened. They also cost more than a printed indicia.
Can I send a 6x9 postcard at the postcard stamp price?
No. Retail postcard prices stop at 4.25 by 6 inches. Bigger cards cost more.
How many words should a yellow letter have?
Short enough to read in 30 seconds: who you are, the property, that you would like to buy it, and how to reach you.
The takeaway
Postcards are cheaper and read on sight; yellow letters cost more but feel personal. At USPS prices effective October 4, 2026, a stamped postcard is $0.65 and a stamped letter $0.82, and retail postcards must stay within 4.25 by 6 inches. Use letters for sensitive lists, postcards for volume and repeat touches, and split-test with a phone number per format.
How do we know this?
We read USPS Notice 123, USPS's postcard size page, and thanks.io's and BILT CRM's pricing pages on November 4, 2026. We did not run a split test for this page.
Sources
- USPS Notice 123, Price List (effective October 4, 2026) (accessed November 4, 2026)
- USPS Postal Explorer, Sizes for postcards (accessed November 4, 2026)
- thanks.io pricing (accessed November 4, 2026)
- BILT CRM pricing (accessed November 4, 2026)